Corrugation and Shoving in Flexible Pavements

Transportation infrastructure is the backbone of any society, facilitating the movement of people and goods. Within this intricate network, flexible pavements play a pivotal role, providing a resilient and adaptable surface for vehicular traffic. However, the journey of these pavements is not always smooth, as they can encounter defects such as corrugation and shoving. In this comprehensive exploration, we will delve into the nuanced world of flexible pavements, dissecting the causes, manifestations, and remedial measures associated with corrugation and shoving. By unraveling these complexities, we aim to empower engineers, construction professionals, and enthusiasts with the knowledge needed to ensure the durability and functionality of our roadways.

Corrugation: A Ripple Effect on Roads

Understanding Corrugation

Corrugation, colloquially known as washboarding, manifests as ripples or waves on the flexible pavement surface, typically oriented perpendicular to the direction of traffic flow. This perplexing phenomenon tends to occur at points where vehicles initiate acceleration and deceleration, creating an uneven road surface that poses challenges to both safety and comfort.

Causes of Corrugation

  1. Weak Sub-grade Conditions The foundation of any flexible pavement lies in its sub-grade, the layer beneath the surface. When this sub-grade is compromised by the presence of highly plastic clays, organic soils, or a high water table, it becomes susceptible to deformation. To counteract this, excavation and replacement with stable materials such as boulders and crushed stones are employed to fortify the sub-grade.
  2. Improper Rolling and Compaction The construction phase is crucial, and improper rolling or inadequate compaction during the installation of flexible pavements can lead to the formation of corrugations. The layers of the pavement must be securely held together to withstand the stresses imposed by vehicular traffic.
  3. Poor Mixing of Surface Course The surface course, comprising bitumen, plays a pivotal role in the stability of flexible pavements. However, if the mixing of the surface course is not meticulous, defects such as corrugation may emerge. These defects can propagate over time with the continuous flow of traffic, exacerbating the issue.
  4. Temperature Effects on Bitumen The temperature during the mixing and rolling of bitumen is critical. High temperatures can compromise the stability of the bitumen mix, leading to the formation of waves or corrugations during the compacting phase. Managing temperature is paramount to ensuring the longevity of the pavement structure.
  5. Weakness in Bottom Layers The integrity of the bottom layers, including the binder course, base course, and sub-base course, is paramount. If these layers are poorly compacted or defectively graded, the surface course is subjected to deformation and depression, ultimately resulting in the formation of corrugations.

Visualizing Corrugations

To comprehend the impact of corrugation, it’s essential to visualize the undulating waves that emerge on the pavement surface (see Fig. 1). These corrugations not only compromise the aesthetics of the road but also pose challenges to vehicle stability and ride comfort.

Shoving: The Pavement’s Plastic Movement

Understanding Shoving

Shoving, another intricate defect observed in flexible pavements, is characterized by the bulging of the pavement surface due to plastic movement. This phenomenon typically occurs at points where vehicles apply brakes or where the pavement interacts with rigid objects, creating a unique set of challenges for pavement engineers.

Causes of Shoving

The causes of shoving often intertwine with those of corrugation, emphasizing the interconnected nature of these pavement defects.

Visualizing Shoving

To grasp the concept of shoving, envision the pavement surface bulging beneath the wheels of a vehicle as it applies brakes or encounters rigid obstacles. This localized deformation can lead to a distorted pavement surface, compromising its structural integrity.

Causes Revisited: A Closer Look

To gain a deeper understanding, let’s revisit the root causes of both corrugation and shoving, examining how each factor contributes to the manifestation of these defects.

  1. Weak Sub-grade Conditions
  • The sub-grade serves as the foundation for the entire pavement structure. When compromised by weak soil, stability issues arise, leading to both corrugation and shoving.
  1. Improper Rolling and Compaction
  • Inadequate compaction during construction disrupts the cohesion between pavement layers, contributing to the formation of both corrugations and shoving.
  1. Poor Mixing of Surface Course
  • Defective mixing of the surface course can result in localized weaknesses, paving the way for both corrugation and shoving.
  1. Temperature Effects on Bitumen
  • Temperature plays a crucial role in the stability of bitumen. High temperatures can lead to deformations that manifest as corrugations and shoving.
  1. Weakness in Bottom Layers
  • The bottom layers, if poorly compacted or graded, become a breeding ground for pavement deformations, giving rise to both corrugation and shoving.

Remedial Measures: Preserving Pavement Integrity

Addressing corrugation and shoving requires a strategic approach. Here, we explore remedial measures that can be employed to restore and preserve the integrity of flexible pavements.

Stabilizing Weak Sub-grade

If the sub-grade soil is identified as a weak link, stabilization becomes imperative. Utilizing suitable stabilizing agents such as lime, cement, or chemical admixtures can enhance the stability of the sub-grade, forming a robust foundation for the pavement structure.

Proper Compaction

In cases where inadequately compacted layers compromise pavement integrity, the remedy lies in removing these layers and reconstructing them with proper compaction. This ensures uniformity and strength throughout the pavement structure.

Sub-surface Drainage

Effective drainage is crucial in mitigating the impact of water on pavement performance. Lowering the water table by implementing a suitable sub-surface drainage system prevents water-induced deformations and contributes to the longevity of the flexible pavement.

Surface Course Correction

In instances where poor mixing of the surface course is identified as a cause, laying another layer with meticulous attention to mixing becomes a remedial measure. This corrective action aims to eliminate defects and restore the surface course to its intended specifications.

The Journey Ahead: A Call to Action

As we navigate the intricate terrain of flexible pavements, understanding the nuances of corrugation and shoving becomes paramount. Armed with this knowledge, professionals in the construction industry can embark on a journey of proactive measures, ensuring the resilience and longevity of our transportation infrastructure.

In conclusion, the world of flexible pavements is multifaceted, with each defect offering insights into the intricacies of construction and material science. By unraveling the complexities of corrugation and shoving, we pave the way for safer, smoother, and more sustainable roadways that stand the test of time. Let this exploration be a catalyst for continuous learning and improvement in the field of pavement engineering, propelling us towards a future where our roads are not just pathways but enduring assets for generations to come.

Scroll to Top